East Lothian Council has launched a Preliminary Market Consultation (PMC) to identify suppliers, funders and developers capable of delivering a new facility at the Brunton site.
The move follows a decision by councillors in August to progress plans for a replacement building. The existing Brunton Theatre has not hosted performances since early 2023 after the discovery of Reinforced Aerated Autoclaved Concrete (RAAC).
Since then, Brunton Theatre Trust has staged performances at alternative venues, including Haddington Corn Exchange and smaller venues in Musselburgh. Meanwhile, council services have relocated, or are in the process of relocating, to other accommodation.
Current estimates place the cost of refurbishment and RAAC remediation at more than £42.2 million. By comparison, demolition and rebuilding would cost around £50.7 million. However, pressures on council finances mean a new facility will require an alternative funding model. This could include commercial investment, government support, grant funding or a combination of sources.
Councillors approved a proposal to test market interest in the redevelopment project. As a result, the Council hopes to gather valuable insights to help shape the next phase of planning.
The consultation also demonstrates East Lothian Council's commitment to redeveloping the site. Plans include a theatre and performance space as part of the development. In addition, commercial uses could be incorporated to help offset costs, subject to the necessary approvals and consents.
Earlier this year, a place-based development survey found strong support for arts provision in Musselburgh. More than 98% of respondents backed the idea of an arts facility in the town. Furthermore, participants suggested a range of potential funding sources. These included Scottish Government support, Arts Council or National Lottery funding, increased commercial activity, Common Good funding, corporate sponsorship, private donations, community ownership and public share offers.
The Council published the PMC through Public Contracts Scotland. The document highlights the opportunity to create a landmark cultural destination in one of Scotland's fastest-growing regions. It also outlines how a new facility could complement local leisure and tourism attractions while serving a growing population.
Council Leader Norman Hampshire said:
"This is a very positive step forward in our work to safeguard accommodation for the arts in Musselburgh.
"The decision to close and mothball the Brunton, which has played a key role at the heart of Musselburgh since 1971, was a very difficult one to take.
"The Preliminary Market Consultation marks the next stage in our efforts to find an affordable solution. We want to maintain the cultural, economic and social benefits that the Brunton Hall has delivered for many years.
"It also demonstrates our ambition for a replacement facility. We want to create a building that people can be proud of, one that celebrates the Brunton Hall's legacy while providing a modern space for community, arts and culture."
Sign up for our communications to receive the latest news and updates in East Lothian.
Please refer to our Privacy Policy.
